View Issue Details
|ID||Project||Category||View Status||Date Submitted||Last Update|
|0017513||phpList 3 application||Subscribe Process||public||29-10-14 15:37||06-10-15 14:03|
|Target Version||next minor||Fixed in Version||3.2.0|
|Summary||0017513: When [CONFIRMATIONURL] (?p=confirm) is loaded, PHPList should check if user is NOT confirmed **before** sending welcome email ag|
|Description||A confirmation email is sent to the list manager and to the subscriber **each time** he loads the [CONFIRMATIONURL] which is included in the message sent upon subscription (the link looks like www.mydomain.com/lists/?p=confirm&uid=XXXX).|
Some users forgets to close the tab in their navigator and each time they launch it, the confirmation emails are sent again, and again and again. I received some of them 6/7 times... and with hundred of new subscribers each day, it's really a problem...
Would it be possible to **check** if the user has already confirmed his subscription **before** that PHPList send confirmation emails (and do nothing if the user has already confirmed) ??
|Steps To Reproduce||- a new user subscribe to a newsletter|
- he receives a welcome message which contains the [CONFIRMATIONURL] link (www.mydomain.com/lists/?p=confirm&uid=XXXX)
- each time he clicks on this link, the confirmation process is run and an email il sent to him, an email is sent to the list manager.
|Tags||No tags attached.|
yes, good point
There is a further problem with the solution to this issue, reported on the user forum https://forums.phplist.com/viewtopic.php?f=37&t=42219
When someone who is already confirmed signs up using another subscribe page that offers a different list then he will not be sent the "welcome" email, because he is already confirmed.
The real cause of the problem seems to be that phplist doesn't hold confirmed/unconfirmed against each subscribe page/list, so I don't see how it can distinguish between the cases of clicking the same confirmation link again, or clicking a confirmation link that is for a different subscribe page/list.
The original issue, of receiving repeated welcome emails, although annoying, seems less of a problem than not sending the welcome email at all after subscribing to a separate list.
Maybe we need to add a timeout. Eg when the last confirmation was sent more than X minutes ago, we can send it again.
That doesn't help though when the page is reloaded on a browser session restore.
||the confirmation is now remembered in the session with "subscriberConfirmed" which is cleared on the subscribe page, so that it will work with a new subscribe page|